A defense medical examination is an evaluation requested for the lawsuit, not an appointment for ongoing treatment. The examiner may offer an opinion about diagnosis, causation, restrictions, or future care. That opinion can be disputed and compared with the treating record.
Receiving the request does not mean the court has rejected your doctors. It means the defense wants additional evidence about a condition involved in the claim. Before attending, review the request and any governing order or agreement with your lawyer.
What controls the examination?
Louisiana Code of Civil Procedure article 1464 calls this an additional medical opinion. For a court-ordered examination, the relevant mental or physical condition must be in controversy and good cause must be shown. The order must identify the examiner and specify the time, place, manner, conditions, and scope.
The article also addresses certain vocational and psychological examinations and limits multiple examinations by physicians in the same specialty for the same injury unless good cause is shown. A request should therefore be evaluated for what it actually seeks, not treated as permission for unlimited testing.
Before the appointment, ask counsel to clarify the proposed tests, expected duration, travel arrangements, records to be supplied, and any issue about another person’s presence or recording. Do not assume that a companion or recording device is permitted without resolving the applicable conditions.
Minors have an express protection under article 1464: a parent, tutor, or legal guardian may be present. The statute provides for court-ordered videotaping if that person cannot attend, subject to its terms and the child’s best interests.
Give an accurate history, including the parts that are difficult to explain
Review your treatment chronology, current medications, prior injuries, surgeries, work duties, and present limitations with your lawyer. If a date is uncertain, identify it as uncertain. If you had symptoms before the incident, explain the earlier condition and what changed afterward.
A description such as “I cannot lift anything” may be inaccurate if you can lift a light item but cannot perform your usual work. Describe the actual limitation. Improvement, variable symptoms, and activities you can still do belong in an honest account alongside the difficulties.
Follow the appointment arrangements made through counsel. Tell the examiner if a movement causes pain or if you do not understand an instruction. Do not exaggerate a response or force a movement merely to demonstrate effort. Concerns about a proposed procedure or the examination’s scope should be raised with your lawyer in advance when possible.
The examiner’s observations may be compared with testimony, records, or other evidence. That is a reason to be accurate and act normally, not to rehearse how to look injured.
What to do after the appointment
Write a factual account for your lawyer while the details are fresh. Include arrival and departure times, who examined you, the tests or movements performed, documents requested, and any issue that appeared to fall outside the agreed scope. Describe any new symptoms without trying to diagnose their cause.
Do not confuse keeping this account with recording the examination itself. Recording and attendance questions should have been addressed under the applicable order or agreement.
Article 1465 provides a process for obtaining a detailed report with findings, test results, diagnoses, and conclusions. It also addresses reciprocal report exchanges and privilege consequences. Your lawyer should handle that request with those effects in mind.
An unfavorable report is evidence to evaluate. Counsel may compare it with the treating providers’ findings, check the history supplied to the examiner, and consider further testimony or expert analysis. The article on medical records in injury claims explains why a complete treatment history matters to that comparison.
The examination is one part of the discovery process authorized by article 1421. Our guide to a Louisiana personal injury lawsuit explains the larger process.
If you need help with a disputed injury claim, our Louisiana personal injury practice can review the medical evidence and examination request. Contact us or call (225) 500-5000.
Editorial & Legal Accuracy Notice (Louisiana)
This article provides general Louisiana legal information, not advice about an individual case. Event dates, policy language, responsible parties, and the evidence may change the analysis.