The right to change Medicare coverage is not necessarily the right to buy a Medigap policy without medical underwriting. Before leaving Medicare Advantage for Original Medicare, determine whether a supplemental insurer must accept your application, what it may charge, and when coverage will begin.
Medicare’s annual election period runs from October 15 through December 7, with changes generally effective January 1. That window allows important coverage changes, but it does not create a new, unrestricted Medigap enrollment right each year. Louisiana has additional protections, including a birthday rule with specific limits.
First, separate the three kinds of coverage
Medicare explains the distinction this way: Original Medicare consists of Parts A and B. Medicare Advantage is an alternative way to receive Medicare benefits through a private plan. Medigap is private supplemental insurance that helps pay certain costs left by Original Medicare. A Medigap policy does not pay Medicare Advantage copayments or deductibles.
Prescription coverage is another part of the decision. Newly sold Medigap policies do not include Part D prescription benefits. Someone returning to Original Medicare may need a separate drug plan and must coordinate its enrollment and effective date.
The enrollment windows do different jobs
Scroll horizontally to see all columns. Use the arrow keys when the table is focused.
| Window or protection | What it does | Important limit |
|---|---|---|
| Annual Medicare election period: October 15–December 7 | Permits annual changes involving Medicare Advantage and drug coverage, including a return to Original Medicare. | Does not itself require a Medigap insurer to accept an applicant without health underwriting. |
| Initial federal Medigap open enrollment | Generally provides a six-month protected buying period beginning with the first month someone is both 65 or older and enrolled in Part B. | It is not a yearly six-month period. Rules about pre-existing-condition waiting periods also require attention. |
| Louisiana Medigap birthday period | Gives an existing Medigap policyholder 63 calendar days beginning on the birthday to make a qualifying change. | The issuer or affiliate and equal-or-lesser-benefit restrictions matter. |
| Federal guaranteed-issue and trial rights | Protect qualifying applicants after specified events, including certain first-year Medicare Advantage changes. | The event, policy choices, application deadline, and evidence must all be checked. |
The initial Medigap window is explained in Medicare’s buying-period guidance. Outside a protected period or applicable guaranteed-issue right, an insurer may ask health questions, charge more, or decline an application, subject to the governing law. Medicare’s switching guidance specifically warns readers to check these issues before dropping existing coverage.
Louisiana’s 63-day birthday rule: four conditions to check
Louisiana R.S. 22:1112(A) creates an annual opportunity for people who already have a Medicare supplement policy on their birthday. Its protections are narrower than an unrestricted right to shop among all insurers.
- Existing coverage: You must have a Medigap policy at the time of your birthday. Having Medicare Advantage alone does not satisfy that requirement.
- Timing: The period begins on your birthday and lasts 63 calendar days. The statute does not describe a period beginning 30 days before your birthday.
- Company: The replacement policy must be offered by the same issuer or an affiliate authorized to do business in Louisiana.
- Benefits: The protection against health-based denial, conditions, or pricing discrimination applies when the standardized plan letter indicates benefits equal to or less than those of your previous plan.
A lower premium does not prove that a policy has equal or lesser benefits. Compare the standardized plan letters and obtain the insurer’s written explanation of the protection being applied. An agent’s statement that two companies are related should also be confirmed with the issuer; a shared sales agency does not establish an insurer affiliation.
The protection against health-based pricing discrimination is not a promise that every applicant will receive the same premium or that the new premium cannot change for otherwise lawful reasons. Ask for the actual quoted premium and its effective date.
Federal trial rights may protect a return from Medicare Advantage
Federal law provides certain trial rights, described in the official Choosing a Medigap Policy guide, pages 15–19. Two common situations are:
- You joined Medicare Advantage when first eligible for Medicare Part A at age 65 and decide within the first year to return to Original Medicare. A qualifying applicant has a right to buy a Medigap policy available in the state, subject to the applicable plan-eligibility rules.
- You dropped a Medigap policy to join Medicare Advantage, or switched to Medicare SELECT, for the first time and decide to return within the first year. The right generally concerns the former Medigap policy if the same company still sells it; specified alternatives apply if it is unavailable.
These are fact-dependent protections. The second situation is not permission to try a succession of Medicare Advantage plans and demand a new Medigap trial right after each one. Other guaranteed-issue events can include a plan leaving Medicare or a service area, or an eligible move outside the plan’s service area. The exact event determines the available policies and deadlines.
For the trial-right situations described in the Medicare guide, applications generally may begin 60 calendar days before the Medicare Advantage coverage ends and must be made no later than 63 calendar days afterward. Confirm the rule that applies to your event. Separate deadlines can govern leaving the plan and arranging Part D coverage.
Medigap Plans C and F are generally unavailable to people newly eligible for Medicare on or after January 1, 2020. A list of guaranteed-issue plan letters should therefore be checked against the person’s original Medicare eligibility date, rather than copied from someone else’s experience.
Louisiana also addresses people leaving employer coverage
R.S. 22:1112(B) provides a separate 63-calendar-day opportunity for a Medicare-eligible person who has no existing Medigap policy and maintained employer health coverage when first becoming Medicare eligible. The period begins when the employer plan terminates, stops providing some or all health benefits, or the individual leaves that plan.
This provision allows purchase of a Medigap policy offered in Louisiana. Its protection against health-based denial, conditions, or pricing discrimination is tied to standardized plan letters for which federal law provides a guaranteed-issue right at the relevant initial Medicare eligibility date. It should not be reduced to a promise that every policy is available on identical terms.
Three examples show why the distinction matters
Existing Medigap policyholder. Marie has Medigap when her birthday arrives. She wants a qualifying equal-or-lesser-benefit policy from the same insurer or its authorized affiliate. The Louisiana birthday provision may protect that transaction if she meets its timing and other conditions. It does not automatically give her the same right with an unrelated insurer.
Longtime Medicare Advantage member. Robert has had Medicare Advantage for several years. He can consider returning to Original Medicare during the fall election period. His birthday alone does not guarantee acceptance into Medigap, because he does not already have a Medigap policy. He needs to establish another protected right or obtain an underwriting decision before relying on supplemental coverage.
Retiree leaving employer coverage. Elaine kept employer health coverage when she became Medicare eligible and has no Medigap policy. She is now leaving the employer plan. Louisiana’s employer-coverage provision may apply, but she still needs to document the triggering date, identify the protected policy choices, and coordinate Medicare enrollment.
These examples illustrate the statutes and enrollment rules. They do not determine any particular person’s eligibility.
What to obtain in writing before changing coverage
- The legal basis for Medigap acceptance: initial open enrollment, a particular guaranteed-issue event, a trial right, or Louisiana’s birthday or employer-coverage provision.
- The policy’s exact plan letter, issuing company, premium, underwriting decision, and any pre-existing-condition waiting-period issue.
- The end date of the existing coverage and the start dates of Original Medicare, Medigap, and any separate Part D plan.
- Confirmation about the doctors, hospitals, prescriptions, and pharmacies that matter to you under the proposed arrangement.
- Copies of termination notices, prior coverage records, applications, and written acceptance—not merely a premium estimate.
Do not assume that an application, a quote, and an issued policy mean the same thing. Resolve acceptance and timing before making an irreversible coverage decision.
Louisiana’s LaSHIP counseling program provides free, unbiased Medicare assistance at 1-800-259-5300. Ask a counselor to work through the relevant dates and documents. People eligible for Medicare before age 65 should specifically ask about the rules applicable to their circumstances; this guide does not attempt to cover every disability-related enrollment protection.
Coverage questions and hospital bills require separate inquiries
Changing insurance does not resolve every existing bill. If a hospital balance remains, the facility’s own assistance policy may warrant review. Our Louisiana hospital financial-assistance comparison explains where to find those terms. When evaluating a facility, our hospital inspection guide addresses a different question: how to read public inspection findings and corrections. Neither process replaces checking insurance coverage and provider participation.
Law and sources current through October 20, 2026. Coverage rights depend on individual enrollment history and the applicable policy.
Return to Louisiana Legal Research for additional guides.