Two Louisiana Coastal Lawsuits: What the Chevron and Devon Orders Decided


November 3, 2026. A Louisiana jury awarded Plaquemines Parish $744.6 million in April 2025. A year later, the U.S. Supreme Court ruled for Chevron on a question of federal jurisdiction. That October, Justice Sonia Sotomayor denied an emergency application filed by Louisiana and Cameron Parish in a different coastal suit. Which decision tells a reader whether Chevron owes the money? The jury supplied the dollar figure. None of the four appellate decisions below directed Chevron to pay it or set it aside as an award of damages. Chevron’s disclosure of the verdict.

The two parishes brought separate cases against different defendants. Their paths crossed because the oil companies invoked the federal-officer removal statute to move litigation from state to federal court. In Plaquemines, the Supreme Court addressed the connection between wartime oil production and federally directed aviation-fuel refining. In Cameron, the question was what should happen to a district court’s order sending the case back to state court while Devon appealed.

Four orders, two cases

Date and caseWhat the court orderedWhat that means
April 17 · Plaquemines v. ChevronThe Supreme Court vacated the Fifth Circuit’s judgment. Chevron had plausibly connected the challenged oil production with its federal wartime refining duties.The court resolved the “relating to” requirement for removing the suit. It did not assess coastal restoration costs.
August 24 · Plaquemines v. ChevronThe Fifth Circuit vacated the district court’s order returning the case to state court. It sent the case to the federal district court and enjoined state proceedings for 60 days unless the appeals court extended or terminated the injunction.The district judge had further work to do. The panel expressly left the merits open.
October 5 · Cameron v. DevonThe Fifth Circuit held that the district court’s remand order was automatically stayed when Devon’s notice of appeal under 28 U.S.C. § 1447(d) was docketed.The order sending the case to state court was held in abeyance while the appeal proceeded. The panel did not decide which alleged conduct caused damage.
October 26 · Louisiana v. DevonJustice Sotomayor denied the state and parish’s application to vacate the stay. The docket records Justice Alito’s recusal.The application produced no order lifting the stay. The docket supplies no explanation for the denial and no new ruling on damages.

Plaquemines Parish: Why the wartime facts mattered

The parish challenged decades of oil operations under Louisiana coastal law. Chevron’s predecessors had agreed to refine aviation gasoline for the federal government during World War II. The contested operations included producing crude oil, a step upstream from refining it. The question was whether that production related closely enough to the companies’ federal work for Chevron to invoke the removal statute.

The Supreme Court held that Chevron did not need to show the government specifically ordered the particular production activity. Chevron plausibly alleged that much of the crude oil produced in Plaquemines went into its own refineries to supply the wartime fuel. That factual connection mattered. The ruling gives a lawyer in another parish a question to investigate: what federal duty did this defendant undertake, and how does the conduct challenged in this suit relate to that duty? A company’s participation in the oil industry, standing alone, does not supply the connection the Court described. Supreme Court opinion, pp. 7–12.

There are two different uses of “remand” in the August order. The Fifth Circuit vacated the federal trial court’s remand to state court, then remanded the matter to the federal trial court for further proceedings. Its 60-day injunction was a separate direction. Calculating 60 days from August 24 cannot establish whether the injunction is in effect today. That requires checking for an extension, termination or later order in appeal No. 23-30336. August 24 order, p. 2.

Cameron Parish: What the October stay preserved

Devon invoked federal grounds that differed from Chevron’s wartime refining contracts. One concerned conservation work tied to the federal government’s property interest in the Rockefeller Wildlife Refuge. The federal district court ordered remand on August 21. Devon appealed and sought to keep that order from taking effect while the Fifth Circuit reviewed it. Opinion and procedural history, pp. 2–4.

On October 5 the Fifth Circuit concluded that the authorized appeal stayed the remand when the notice of appeal was docketed. Otherwise, returning the case immediately could defeat the appellate review Congress had allowed. The ruling concerned who would exercise jurisdiction during that appeal. The October 26 Supreme Court docket entry answered a still narrower question: the applicants did not obtain emergency relief from the stay. Reading that entry as a decision about Devon’s responsibility for land loss would give it a meaning its text does not support. Fifth Circuit stay opinion · Emergency docket 26A499.

How to follow the right docket

For Plaquemines, start with Supreme Court No. 24-813, Fifth Circuit No. 23-30336 and Eastern District of Louisiana No. 2:18-cv-05189. For Cameron, start with Western District of Louisiana No. 2:26-cv-01335, Fifth Circuit No. 26-30505 and Supreme Court No. 26A499. In the district court the Cameron case is also indexed under Burlington Resources Oil & Gas. The defendant named in an appellate caption can differ from the name used to find the trial docket. Cameron district docket identification.

For a current litigation decision, obtain the latest trial and appellate docket sheets, follow any new civil-action number, and read the order itself. The Eastern District issued a general assignment order explaining that some previously removed cases receive new numbers if removed again. A docket snapshot or the date on a news story cannot establish the present enforceability of the verdict. This account describes the cited rulings through October 26. Eastern District assignment order · Federal docket search.

For related questions about how an industrial settlement defines which losses and claims it covers, see our Louisiana industrial-damage settlement guide. More case and statute guides appear in Louisiana Legal Research.