An accessibility violation can be relevant evidence after a ramp injury, but it does not by itself prove every part of a Louisiana damages claim. The investigation must establish the applicable requirements, the condition encountered, who was responsible for it, and how it contributed to the injury.
For example, a wheelchair might tip after a wheel catches at a transition even if the ramp’s overall grade is acceptable. A person using a walker might slip on water at a landing. Measuring only the slope would leave important parts of either event unexplained.
Identify the ramp and the rule that applies
The U.S. Access Board’s ramp guide explains technical requirements for ramps and curb ramps. It distinguishes running slope from cross slope and addresses landings, width, handrails, edge protection, and surfaces. Requirements and exceptions vary with the feature. A curb ramp should not be evaluated by copying every detail from a diagram of an entrance ramp.
Obtain construction and alteration dates, plans, permits, and records of later changes. Identify whether the location is a business entrance, government facility, public sidewalk, or another setting. The applicable legal framework and responsible parties can differ.
An older building is not automatically exempt from accessibility duties. The Justice Department’s guidance for businesses explains both continuing barrier-removal obligations where removal is readily achievable and the limited protection for certain existing elements that complied with earlier standards. Alterations can change the analysis. A reliable assessment identifies the particular element and its history instead of assigning one compliance label to the entire building.
Document the route the person actually used
Photograph the approach, ramp, landing, doorway, and destination together before concentrating on details. Mark the direction of travel and the location where the movement changed. Preserve original photographs and video with their dates. A later measurement should identify whether the surface, mat, handrail, or entrance layout had changed since the incident.
Scroll horizontally to see all columns. Use the arrow keys when the table is focused.
| Feature | What to record | Connection to investigate |
|---|---|---|
| Grade and side-to-side slope | Measurement location, direction, equipment, and method | Did the device roll, drift, tip, or become difficult to control? |
| Transitions and surface | Lips, cracks, loose mats, debris, moisture, and repairs | Did a wheel, foot, or walking aid catch or lose traction there? |
| Landing and doorway | Clear space, door movement, obstacles, and the person’s path | Was there room to stop, turn, or operate the door? |
| Handrails and exposed edges | Location, continuity, condition, and attachment | Did a support fail or a wheel leave the usable surface? |
| Route instructions | Signs, visibility, opening hours, and any alternate entrance | Was the proposed accessible route identifiable and available at that time? |
Measurements need a reproducible method. Record units and whether a reported slope is a percentage, ratio, or angle. Keep the location of each reading so an average does not obscure a short irregular section. An appropriate professional can evaluate disputed dimensions and applicable tolerances.
Do not recreate a fall or ask someone to cross an unsafe ramp to demonstrate the problem. Photographs, measurements, records, and a properly planned inspection can document the condition without exposing another person to it.
Connect the condition to the movement and injury
Preserve the complete camera sequence when available. Ask witnesses where they were and what they saw before the fall, including the person’s direction, assistance, and contact with the surface. Separate observation from a conclusion that the ramp was simply too steep.
Identify the actual wheelchair, walker, cane, or other device used, together with relevant condition and adjustment information. Record weather, footwear, carried items, and any assistance. These details help test competing explanations; they should not be filled in from assumptions about a person’s disability.
Medical records address injury and treatment. Scene evidence addresses the event. Compare both timelines, including any early uncertainty about the mechanism or later change in symptoms. A measured departure from a standard still needs a supported connection to the claimed harm.
Trace responsibility and notice
For an owner or custodian claim under Civil Code article 2317.1, knowledge or what reasonable care should have revealed, preventability, failure to exercise reasonable care, and causation require examination. Other rules may govern particular defendants or conditions.
Request leases, maintenance assignments, prior complaints, inspection records, and repair communications. Determine who built or altered the ramp and who placed a temporary mat or portable device. A contractor’s involvement, an owner’s title, and a tenant’s daily operation may answer different questions about responsibility.
Our guide to fault after a Louisiana fall explains the importance of the property setting. The article on witness evidence addresses preserving the sequence. Our Baton Rouge premises liability practice evaluates control, notice, and causal evidence alongside the accessibility questions.
Editorial & Legal Accuracy Notice (Louisiana)
Accessibility duties and state injury claims require separate analysis of the facility, applicable standards, incident date, and evidence.