A driver leaves work in a company uniform and causes a crash on the way home. The employer’s name on a badge does not settle whether the employer must answer for the collision. The trip’s purpose, the driver’s instructions, and the connection to assigned work are the important facts.
The ordinary commute rule
Louisiana Civil Code article 2320 addresses an employer’s responsibility for damage caused by an employee in the exercise of the functions for which the person is employed. In its April 2026 decision in Lacy v. Ibarra, the Louisiana Supreme Court reiterated that travel to or from work usually falls outside that course and scope. The employee there was driving his personal vehicle to his regular job. The Court dismissed the claim against the employer.
The same reasoning generally applies to an ordinary trip home after a shift. The fact that the employee worked earlier that day or that the employer benefits from employees arriving at work does not by itself turn every commute into company business.
When the trip may be part of the job
The Lacy opinion discusses narrow situations in which travel can be employment-related, including an assigned duty to perform along the way, employer-provided transportation, expenses or wages tied to the travel, or a special work mission. These are fact-dependent possibilities, not automatic exceptions whenever a worker receives a car allowance or uses a personal car.
For example, an instruction to deliver equipment to a customer after closing is different from driving directly home. A technician sent from one work site to another presents different facts from an office worker’s routine departure. Ask what the worker was directed to do at the time of the crash, where the worker was headed, and whether the route and timing served that task.
A mileage payment needs context
In Lacy, relocation payments included an item called mileage, but they were unrelated to the driver’s actual trip to work on the day of the crash. The Court said those payments did not turn the ordinary commute into work travel. Payroll records alone may therefore be misleading. Compare the payment agreement with trip logs, reimbursement submissions, and any employer direction about that particular drive.
The opinion also explains that workers’ compensation concepts can help analyze travel but are distinct from an employer’s tort responsibility to an injured third party. Avoid treating a workers’ compensation label as a final answer to a road user’s claim.
Which records answer the question?
Preserve dispatch messages, work orders, calendar invitations, mileage claims, fuel-card records, GPS data where available, and the driver’s stated destination. Identify whether the car belonged to the worker or employer, but remember that ownership alone is not the whole course-and-scope test. Insurance coverage requires the actual policy terms and should be reviewed separately from who was at fault.
A crash victim may still have a claim against a negligent driver even when the employer is outside the case. Our commercial vehicle accident practice page, article on food delivery driver accident liability, and guide to potential defendants after a commercial truck crash explain related responsibility questions. If a trip crossed the line between a commute and an assignment, contact us with the route and work instructions for a focused review.
This article gives general information about Louisiana employer liability in commute crashes. Specific assignments, travel payments, policy language, and the timing of the trip can change the result.