A shopper falls near the dairy case. A manager says the camera system overwrote the recording before anyone asked for it. The missing footage may have shown the spill, the fall, or neither. In Louisiana, the useful questions are what each camera covered, when the file disappeared, and what other evidence can still show about the floor condition.
Why the minutes before the fall matter
Louisiana’s merchant liability statute, La. R.S. 9:2800.6, requires proof that the condition posed an unreasonable, foreseeable risk; the merchant created it or knew or should have known about it before the fall; and the merchant failed to use reasonable care. For constructive notice, the statute asks whether the condition existed long enough that reasonable care would have discovered it. Video of only the instant of the fall may leave that timing unanswered.
A camera facing the aisle for the prior half hour could show a leaking container, a cart tracking liquid, an employee passing, or an area that was clear shortly beforehand. It may also show that a hazard appeared only seconds before the fall. The full interval and the camera angle matter more than a freeze-frame of the person on the floor.
Identify the recording before it is overwritten
Write down the store location, date, approximate time, aisle, register or entrance used, and any visible camera positions. Ask promptly for preservation of the original files from all cameras that may cover the area, approach, and aftermath, with time before and after the event. Request the camera-system clock information too; a displayed time can differ from actual time. Keep a copy of the request and the response.
Incident reports, photographs, cleaning logs, inspection records, witness names, receipts, and emergency-call records may help establish where and when the event happened. Ask whether a manager viewed, downloaded, or sent footage before it was deleted. A phone recording of a monitor is useful to locate the event, but the source file and its context are better evidence if they still exist.
Deletion does not automatically prove the store was at fault
Some systems overwrite recordings in the ordinary course; there is no safe universal assumption about how long a store keeps footage. Nor does the absence of a video itself establish that a spill existed for a legally sufficient time. The Louisiana Supreme Court in Reynolds v. Bordelon held that Louisiana does not recognize a separate tort claim for negligent destruction of evidence. It identified possible remedies under evidence, discovery, and contract law, depending on the circumstances. Intentional conduct or a court order raises different questions. A lawyer should review the actual preservation history before asking a court for relief.
If the store says a file is gone, ask which cameras were searched, who performed the search, what date range was checked, when the system overwrote the footage, and whether exports, cloud copies, or insurer copies exist. Keep the reply rather than assuming the answer resolves the underlying fall claim.
Build the claim from what remains
Photographs taken soon after the fall may show the surface, the size and location of a spill, shoe marks, or a lack of warning signs. A witness might have seen the condition before the fall; another may only have seen the aftermath. Distinguish those accounts. Medical records can connect injuries to the event but usually do not establish how long a floor hazard existed.
For broader premises proof, see our slip and fall practice page, our Louisiana commercial-premises guide, and our article on fault and notice in a Louisiana slip and fall. If a store video may be disappearing, contact us with the location, time, and any preservation request so the evidence trail can be evaluated promptly.
This article provides general information about Louisiana merchant claims and missing video. The result depends on the condition, timing, preservation history, and available evidence.